James Baldwin

Fiction 1956 | 159 pages

(still technical challenges, so I re-titled this book!)  Giovanni's Room is the real name!

So, truly, is becoming an adult so difficult?  For David, who loves Giovanni and simultaneously loves his ex-girlfriend, Hella. it is that difficult.  There is so much shame, so much secrecy, so much dirt and rot and filth, and at times, so much love ...  how does someone live with that?  *SPOILER ALERT* Giovanni doesn't live with it.  He dies.  Hells doesn't live with it.  She goes home to her parents in the Midwest.  David ... does he stay in Paris, or return to America?  America, I think.

This is a sad, gripping novel, magnified by the times.  We don't know exactly when the story occurs, but since it was copyrighted in 1956, we know it takes place 70 years ago or so.  David cannot face his attraction to men or his bisexuality.  And his difficult introverted struggle is what Giovanni’s Room is about.  Giovanni's room, where David discovers his sexuality.  Giovanni’s room, filthy and small and decrepit.  Giovanni's room, where shame, secrecy, love, discovery, wonder and fear lived so excruciatingly large.

And then there is Baldwin’s writing.

James Baldwin, if this book is any indication among his 17 published works, is astounding, exquisite, nearly unparalleled as a writer.  What a beautiful writer he is!  Spectacular use of the language.  A flow and a beat that draws you in.  A plot that keeps you right here, turning the page.

Two of my favorite lines from Giovanni's Room:

"Life in that room seemed to be occurring underwater, as I say, and it is certain I underwent a sea change there."  Pg 85. A gorgeous, subtle metaphor.  And ...

"Behind the counter sat one of those absolutely inimitable and indomitable ladies, produced only in the city of Paris ... " (pg 50).  I had to look up both of the "big" words in this sentence, but once I did, I had such a strong visual and visceral reaction to these women ... I can picture them most certainly, sitting at their cash registers, even today, a few days later.

Oh yes, read this classic from the Goodreads Book of the Year list for 1956.  Certainly!

August 2025