Author Archives: Andrea Sigetich

How to Read a Book

Monica Wood

Fiction 2024/ 280 pages

three-hearts

How to Read a Book started out with interesting characters and plot.  We have three major characters. Violet, our narrator, is 22 and was just released from prison, where she served about 1.5 years for driving drunk and killing a woman who was driving in the opposite direction.  Harriet is the volunteer who led a Book Club in the women's prison, two hours a week, for women who were interested in reading together, including Violet.  Violet happens upon Harriet in “the Outs” when she begins to live again in the real world in Portland, Maine.  Frank is a handyman who does odd jobs for Harriet, and is the husband of Lorraine, the woman who was killed by Violet.

While Wood develops each of these characters well, she does not quite take advantage of the relationships they could have together.  Especially, she does not develop Violet and Frank's relationship very well.  This is a missed opportunity, I believe.

Yet, the first two-thirds of the story is engaging, especially when Violet takes a job working with three African grey parrots.

I'm the last third, everyone turns romantic and falls in love with someone or another.  I found this rather irritating ... like a romance novel plopped itself into the novel.

But the end comes around and redeems the novel.

It is a fun, light read, especially given the topic.  You may enjoy it, or you may not. I would not suggest you urgently run out and buy it.

June 2026

Theo of Golden

Allen Levi

Fiction 2023 | 387 pages

two-hearts

I belong to a Facebook group, Book Club Favorites.  (Unfollowed two other groups.  Book readers are extremely prolific!

Anyway, over the last few months, Theo of Golden received an unbelievable number of posts and incited a plethora of discussion.

"You must read this book.  I loved it!”

"I fell asleep reading it.  Boring."

"An inspirational book about kindness."

"Too spiritual."

'I don't need a feel-good book to tell me to be kind."

"Might be my favorite book of all time."

"Way over-hyped."

"Loosely disguised Jesus figure."

I was curious to see where I would land.  There was very little middle ground. Readers loved it or hated it.

Virtually everyone wrote about the story, and no one wrote about the writing.  I will change that direction with my review.

Theo is a well-traveled, wealthy man of 86 who decides to move south from New York City for a year or so.  He moves to Golden, Georgia, and meets and befriends many people in this small Southern town.  On one of his first days, he enters The Chalice ... a coffee shop that makes European coffee just the way he likes it.  On the walls of The Chalice are 92 penciled and pen&ink portraits, created by a local artist.  We learn about how Theo buys each portrait, one at a time, and gives it to the person in the portrait, nearly always inspiring deep conversation. Theo is generous, kind, compassionate, and a superb listener.

That is the story line, and it is an interesting one. 

Unfortunately, I felt the writing was awful.  I don't know if Allen Levi did this on purpose, but it wrecked the book for me.  The character of Theo is one-dimensional, tracing paper thin in character development, sophomoric, shallow.  There is no depth, no texture, no nuance in his personality.  Much as I love debut novels, I will not be looking forward to his second book.

And the ending is contrived, all too convenient. Writing a letter to close up all the loose ends the author didn’t manage to do in the plot line is also a sign of an unsophisticated author.

I cannot think of a single person I would recommend read Theo of Golden. Therefore, by definition, this book receives two hearts.

June 2026

American Dirt

Jeanine Cummins

Fiction 2019 | 380 pages

four-hearts

In Chapter one, a Mexican family in Acapulco is celebrating a quinceañera at a backyard barbecue at Sebastian and Lydia's home. In the first five pages of American Dirt, sixteen members of one family are murdered by a drug cartel.  Sebastian, who is managing the barbecue at his home, is a journalist who reports the truth about the drugs cartels that have overrun Acapulco.  Only his wife Lydia and their son Luca survive the bloodbath, as they were in the house.

This dramatic novel proceeds from there as we follow Lydia and eight-year-old Luca attempt to find safety, knowing they are being tracked by el jefe of the cartel.  We are with them as they make the long journey, traveling all the way up Mexico to reach el Norte.  They travel much of the time on the roofs of la bestia, which is a freight train.  They constantly are on the alert for, and numerous times encounter,  police, cartel members, law enforcement agents, ICE agents, border patrol. And yet, they travel as immigrants and find many people along the in small towns who help them with food and water, and occasionally a place to sleep.

This is all complicated by a friend Lydia made before the day of the killings.  Javier met her in the bookstore she owns in Acapulco.  As their friendship deepens, we learn that Javier is a jefe in the largest, most powerful cartel.  He was responsible for the deaths of Lydia's family. He tracks Lydia and Luca as they attempt to find safety, 

The writing is very clean, there is considerable suspense, and we get a view of life through a migrant's eyes,

Many literary reviewers panned the book for its lack of authenticity, arguing it capitalized on the suffering of migrants without demonstrating a genuine, nuanced understanding of Mexican culture or the sociopolitical landscape.  Ms. Cummins is a white woman of Puerto Rican descent.  Not knowing about this criticism, I took American Dirt at face value and found it to be well worth my time.  I did learn a lot about the courage and commitment it takes to arrive at our Southern border. I did also think it bogged down a bit in places, because the (literal) landscape never changes.

Besides our main characters, Lydia and her son Luca, we meet others traveling the same path.  Soledad and Rebeca are teenage sisters.  Their interaction and reaction to the travel is enlightening, often heartwarming.  Lydia takes them under her wing, and these four travel together for many miles and many days.

I recommend American Dirt.  It is an engaging and powerful read.

May 2026

 

Many Books

Andrea Sigetich

Many genres | Thousands of pages

four-hearts

It has been ten years today since I started my blog, Dusty Shelves.  Hard to believe!  I still enjoy writing it and hope you still enjoy reading it too, at least once in a while.  First book I blogged on was Dead Wake by Erik Larson.  It received four hearts. Here is what the hearts mean.

four-heartsLike it a lot or loved it; I recommend it; put it on your list!

three-heartsLike it; I recommend, with some reservations.

two-heartsI don’t recommend it, though it was compelling enough for me to finish reading.

one-heartI couldn’t get through it

May 2026

People of the Book

Geraldine Brooks

Historical Fiction 2008/ 372 pages

three-hearts

Geraldine Brooks’s People of the Book is a historical fiction novel about a book conservator named Dr. Hanna Heath and her intensive research on the history of the famous Sarajevo Haggadah, rediscovered in 1894 in Sarajevo.  Hannah says that she doesn’t restore books, she conserves them.  We follow her from her home in Sydney across the world in 1996.  The book is an imagined history following the real clues found in the manuscript, and the novel jumps back and forth between Hanna’s findings and historical events that brought the book to its current home in the National Museum of Bosnia and Herzegovina in Sarajevo, Bosnia.

People of the Book is a fascinating, deep read.  Brooks is a truly excellent author and has written many laudable books.  Hanna must hypothesize what might have led to her finding an insect wing, a wine stain, saltwater, a white hair, and the absence of silver feather and rose clasps on the book.  While Brooks must imagine the scenarios that lead to each of these objects, she makes up realistic, rich, believable scenarios, with profound emotional intensity and strong characters.  All these discoveries are fiction, however the book itself is inspired by a true story. 

People of the Book is also quite a challenging read.  At least, I found it so.  The fictional pieces take place in a geography I simply do not know:  Vienna, Sarajevo, Bosnia, Croatia, Herzegovina, Seville, Córdoba, Venice,  Serbia, Yugoslavia.  And the discoveries happen in historical times I know nothing about, such as The Inquisition. According to Brook’s telling, the items are introduced into the book in 1480, 1492, 1609, 1894, and 1940.

It took me many days to read this fine work.  It is NOT a beach read.  But it is a learning experience all on its own and I do recommend it.

May 2026

The Unlikely Pilgrimage of Harold Fry

Rachel Joyce| Fiction

2015, 384 pages

Made it half-way through.  I found The Unlikely Pilgrimage of Harold Fry to be Insipid, implausible, simple, contrived.

Harold sits at breakfast one day with his wife and opens a letter from a long-ago colleague, Queenie Hennessy.  Queenie tells him she is in hospice in Berwick-upon-Tweed, which is some 600 miles north of him, and is dying of cancer.  He believes he likely has some unfinished business with Queenie.  He writes her a short note and goes to the post to send it to her.  But he walks past the first postal box and keeps going, past the second and third.  By the afternoon he has decided that Queenie will only stay alive as long as he keeps walking forwards her.  And so he does.  

What I find implausible is that by the evening, when he calls home, his wife Maureen knows that he is five miles north.  What wife would not throw a small pack in the car with e few clothes, a pair of shoes, his cell phone, and maybe some snacks, and take it to her husband?  Even if their relationship has seen better days?

What I find both insipid and simple is that he meets people who allegedly give him insight.  But what he hears is not insightful.  Only platitudes, and words that remind him of his past.

The story is contrived … forced, artificial … only the fantasy of the author with no real story.  And Harold Fry has no emotional pallet, no depth.

And so I am moving on to whatever is next on my shelf.

May 2026

Heartwood

Amity Gaige

Fiction 2025 | 325 pages

four-hearts

The pink bandana.  A small item, that plays a large part.  I was surprised at the climax.  I did not quite see the situation resolving the way it did ...

Valerie Gillis is a 42-year-old woman, her trail name is Sparrow, who becomes lost near the northern terminus of the Appalachian Trail, while hiking the AT.  She is not a highly competent outdoors woman.  She doesn't know how to start a fire with the six matches she has.  And yet Lieutenant Bev Miller, one of Maine's few women game wardens, leads her teams of hundreds and hundreds of searchers in the Maine woods, searching for Valerie.

As with Sea Wife by the same author, just a few blog posts ago, Gaige creates strong and nuanced characters.  We learn much about the personalities, motivations, and inspirations of both Valerie and Bev.  There are other supporting characters, including Valerie’s partner, her parents, other hikers who are interviewed, and some of the searchers.  But I think my favorite of the supporting characters is Lena, and older woman in a wheel chair who lives in an assisted living community and gets the idea that she knows something about the case of the missing Ms. Gillis.  She is quirky, brilliant, delightful.

We follow the journey over many days (I won’t say how many; that wood be a spoiler!) until a resolution is reached.  The resolution is satisfying and fills the gaps.  In the meantime, we also learn about the unique fortitude and quirkiness of Mainers.

No question, read this book, especially if you like the woods, and enjoy good writing!

May 2026

 

Judge Stone

Viola Davis and James Patterson

Fiction 2026 | 432 pages

four-hearts

A marvelous novel! Could hardly put it down.  This is the story of Judge Mary Stone, the first black woman circuit court judge elected to serve in the present-day town of Union Springs, Alabama, population 3314.

The collaboration between Viola Davis and James Patterson is, I believe, much better than other writing partnerships he has established.  The transition from author to author is smooth.  I could not tell who wrote what.

The primary legal and moral dilemma is the case against the local physician, Dr. Bria Gaines, who is charged with a felony for performing an abortion.  This mirrors the laws that exist today in many of the southeast states, especially since 2022 when the Supreme Court overturned the right to a safe and legal abortion. When Dr. Gaines is arrested for performing an illegal abortion on a 13-year-old girl, Judge Stone must preside over a trial that ignites a national firestorm. As the case draws intense media scrutiny, political pressure from the state’s highest offices, and escalating violence from white-supremacist groups, she is forced to confront her own traumatic past while fighting for justice in a community tearing itself apart.

While the legal manifestations are central to this novel, I particularly liked the manner in which Mary Stone was presented. We focus, yes, on the very visible legalities, but Mary Stone is not only shown as the role she sits in ... a black circuit court judge, but we also see her personality, context, background, values, philosophies, and current life circumstances.  She is written not just in the role she holds, but as a complete human being.  This perspective is utterly delightful.

There is no question ... you may be very interested in reading Judge Stone.  I recommend it wholeheartedly.

May 2026

 

 

The Nightingale

Kristin Hannah

Historical Fiction 2015 | 760 pages

four-hearts

Isabelle Rossignol is ten years younger than her sister Vianne Mauriac..  From the time she was quite young, she was rebellious, reckless, resolute, brave, impetuous, strong, passionate. A foil to her older sister.  But it was the 1940s and Germany had just occupied France.  Unabashedly and with no apparent fear, Isabelle began as a teenager to fight the German occupation.  She was an integral part of the French Resistance.  First delivering papers to mailboxes all over her home town of Carriveau she soon graduates to leading downed RAF and American pilots over the border to safety in Spain, guiding them up and down the Pyrenees. avoiding the Gestapo, German police and later, incredibly, French police.  She eventually led 117 men to safety until she was captured.  Her code name, The Nightingale, became well known among resistance workers and eventually the Germans.  The Germans couldn’t fathom that The Nightingale  was a woman. This part of the book is based in non-fiction.

This is her story.  In pure Kristin Hannah style, this novel is extremely well researched.  Her writing as always draws you in and engages you, heart and soul. About 400 pages in, we encounter a difficult time, a gruesome and disturbing part of the book, when some of our characters are violently herded into cattle cars, tortured, and transported to work camps and concentration camps. 

Overall, the story is very rich, with lots of depth, and visually astonishing.  It is absolutely a page turner.  Even if you are late to get to this epic, as I was, it is definitely a Kristin Hannah to go back and read.

May 2026

Buckeye

Patrick Ryan

Fiction 2025 | 464 pages

four-hearts

Cal and Becky Jenkins and Felix and Margaret Salt, along with their sons Skip and Tom, tell a profound story from the 1940s through the late 20th century.  Richly written, with extraordinary character development, we follow these families against a backdrop of WWII and the Vietnam War.  Home is the small town of Bonhomie Ohio.  

There are themes of love loss, abandonment, death, grief, happiness, friendship, betrayal, loyalty.  An affair between Cal Jenkins and Margaret Salt during WWII binds their families together with consequences that unfold over decades.  The characters are complex and multi-dimensional.  Take for example Cal, who is unable to serve in the war due to a disability, and his wife Becky, who is a seer who can communicate with the dead.  Felix enlists in the Navy and really has no idea what to do with his attraction to men, and not to his wife.  Margaret doesn’t ever warm up to motherhood and eventually abandons them all, adding greater complexity to the interpersonal relationships.

Someone described this book as slow-paced.  I don’t think that is true, though I did find myself wanting to savor it, rather than rush through.

I recommend Buckeye, no hesitation!

April 2026