Category Archives: Uncategorized

Whistler

Ann Patchett

Fiction 2026 / 295 pages

three-hearts

It felt like Patchett decided she needed to publish another novel but didn't really have a story to tell.  So, she takes a woman in her fifties, Daphne, and has her run into her second stepfather at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York city, where she is spending the day with her husband Jonathon.  It has been 44 years since Daphne has seen Eddie, her mother's second husband of three.  The novel is about her and Eddie in the present day.  Interesting, but not compelling or terribly meaningful.

Given that introduction, Ann Patchett's writing is quite good, especially her characters.  The relationship between Eddie and Daphne is astounding!  She rounds out her weak plot with some excellent storytelling. Particularly interesting was the story of the car accident Eddie and Daphne were in 44 years ago, which led to her mom leaving Eddie.

I should have read my blog before diving into Whistler.  I gave two other Ann Patchett books two hearts, and one received three hearts.

If you like Ann Patchett, definitely read this one.  If you are looking for a quick and light read, Whistler will do you well.  So, a mixed recommendation.

August 2026

Mad Mabel

Sally Hepworth

Fiction 2026 | 347 pages

four-hearts

It was a challenge to come up with an overall descriptor for this novel.  As I told a few people while I was reading it, it is an "unusual" book.

Some descriptors from reviews as well as my own thoughts: suspense, humor, twist-filled, darkly funny, haunting, heartbreaking, emotional, deep characters, light, page-turner.  

A few reviewers described it as a "character study" which I never knew as a style of book, but it seems the most accurate to me.

81-year Elsie Mabel Fitzpatrick has lived on Kenny Lane for 50 years.  It is a small street behind retail shops in Melbourne.  Not high end economically.

"Mabel?  (Her name then, but not now), has a reputation as "Mad Mabel."  She is the youngest person ever tried and committed of murder in Australia, at 15.  When one of her neighbors on Kenny Street dies of natural causes and she finds his body, the community at large thrusts itself back into history, to the days of "Mad Mabel" and begins to see her ... now Elsie ... as the potential murderer.

Elsie is a curmudgeonly 82-year-old with lots of energy and actually a big heart, which doesn't really develop until her 80s. During the present -day time frame of this book, she develops relationships with Persephone, a 7-year-old who adopts her; Nugget, a rather obnoxious dog that belonged to the man who died, and Elsie can't see going to a shelter; and a number of the quieter, more recluse women on the small street.  She has seen a lot of death as a child and is unfairly accused of more than one death before she reaches adulthood.  The narrative excellently presents a dual time line, with the sections labeled "Then" and "Now."  The structure to keep us in these two time lines is a pair of You Tube digital creators who decide to capture her life story, and also become her friends.  A great mirror for an 81-year-old!

Not depressing or scary, Mad Mabel is actually an enjoyable read.  I recommend it without hesitation.

Calamity Club

Kathryn Stockett

Fiction 2026 | 646 pages

four-hearts

Kathryn Stockett is a wizard with characters.  Meg, Birdie, Frances, Charlie have such depth; such nuance; are so differentiated one from the other; wear their values on their sleeves; take action, each in their own profound way; love so differently.  She makes me  feel like I know each of them.  No, better than that, she makes me WANT to know them!  And then you add in her minor characters ... Esmerelda, Jack, Trixie and Dixie, Mrs. Tartt, Garnet Pittman ... and you have a roomful of people to invite over for homemade chocolate mouse and to spend the evening.  What great visualizing and creating Stockett can do!  

It is 1933 in Mississippi at the height of the Great Depression and Prohibition.  Many, both rich and poor, are living day-to-day on the margin. Meg, 11, is one if the unadoptable “big girls” at the Lafayette County Orphan Asylum, who fights each day to keep her spirit.  The orphan's Director, Mrs. Pittman, really has it in for Meg. She isolated her in a mildewed room, gradually removing her "privileges" of eating meals with other girls snd attending classes.

Birdie jumps on a train to ask her sister Frances for some money to help tide her and her mother over,  Her sister Birdie has married well.  But not well enough to overcome the travails of the Depression. While there, she joins her sister in volunteering at the orphanage, meets and falls head-over-heels for Meg, trying to lift Meg's spirits and help her survive,

And Charlie, Meg's birth mom, is a woman with a past, running low on luck but driven by fire, fury, and grit. When their fates converge, they come up with an audacious plan to take back control of their lives. Together, they form an unlikely sisterhood at a very difficult time in in the world with lots of social, political, and emotional toil and upheaval.

Eventually, after sending Frances and their mom away to live in Birdie's home for a while, and to find Frances' husband Rory who wit absconded with all the valuables in the house, seemingly to get some money, for himself.  Birdie gets it firmly in her mind to start a business, a Dime-a-Dance club. This is where Calamity Club gets a bit tedious, I think.  Stockett repeats herself A LOT in this section.  Even I know that Frances is the password, how and why to buy 99 widows, and what a mangle machine is.  The business is interesting, and many of our minor characters come to fruition in this section.  This ALMOST moved it a three-heart rating for me, but others found the business quite interesting, and it is, after all, a compelling venture. 

Eventually, the wrap up is believable, though I wish we saw more of Meg in the end.

I recommend it.  Yes, it is nearly 700 pages long. I recommend it for the fascinating characterizations and intriguing plot.

August 2026

The City

Dean Koontz

Fiction 2014 | 398 pages

four-hearts

The 57-year-old narrator in our story writes about his youth … mostly from age eight to age 11.  Jonah Kirk lives in the city and we learn about the events and experiences that shape his life as a pianist, a lover of art, and ultimately a songwriter.  The book introduces readers to Jonah’s complex family dynamics, his early recognition as a musical prodigy, and his encounters with various characters that deeply influence his life

But the city (New York City) is not just an ordinary city.  Mixing some magic and surrealism into this tale makes the story intriguing, entertaining, a bit unbelievable.  For “the city” is also A character whom Jonah names Miss Pearl.  Miss Pearl plays a small, but very important, role.  Jonah refers to her as his supernatural mentor.  She is “the city.”  As she comprises a tiny strand from each resident, Miss Pearl is literally the whole population of the city and provides Jonah with occasional insight and perspective.

Koontz’s writing is delicious.  He draws you in, moves forward at a good pace, shares action as well as well-developed character insight, displays significant imagination.  I borrowed this read from Brian when I ran out of books on our camping trip to the Tetons.  I would not hesitate to read another Koontz, and yes, I surely recommend this one.  You just may fall in love with Jonah.

July 2026

 

The Bean Trees

Barbara Kingsolver

Fiction 1988 | 242 pages

four-hearts

With confidence and self-reliance instilled in her by her loving mother, “Missy” Greer is able to buy a very rough VW Beetle and take off west from rural Kentucky to find her own path after she graduates high school. She has to start her Beetle with one foot on the ground, to get it rolling.  She renames herself Taylor when she passes a road sign for Taylorsville.

When she stops for car repairs in Oklahoma, Taylor encounters a Cherokee woman, who gives her a “baby” and tells her that no one else can care for the child. Unsure what to do, Taylor takes the silent toddler to a motel. She discovers evidence that the child has been physically abused and molested. Sickened, Taylor resolves to take care of the child, naming her Turtle, and continues to drive west until two flat tires force a stop in Tucson, Arizona. Because Taylor can’t afford to replace the tires, she decides to stay in Tucson and look for work.

Mattie, who owns the tire shop, offers her a job which Taylor accepts, as she hasn’t a penny to her name.  Taylor meets Lou Ann, who becomes her roommate and best friend.  Lou Ann has a young son, Dwayne Ray.  Mattie eventually reveals that she provides sanctuary to migrants from Central America who seek political asylum in the US. She introduces Taylor to Estevan and Esperanza, a young couple from Guatemala who were forced to enter the country without authorized documents. These characters eventually form their own small family.

It takes her a long while, but eventually, Turtle begins to open up and interact with the world. She’s fascinated by vegetables and plants, starting to speak by pointing out beans in the garden. Her first vocabulary words are bean, “tato,” and carrot. Taylor grows to love Turtle like a daughter and is encouraged by the child’s resiliency despite the terrible situation she endured early in her life. 

The story picks up from there as we watch the evolving and fascinating characters of Taylor, Lou Ann, Turtle, Mattie, Estevan and Esperanza.  Kingsolver is a master at producing richly-nuanced characters as well as intriguing plots.

The Bean Trees (first published in 1988) is the first novel by Barbara Kingsolver. No wonder she went on to become a renowned author with seventeen published books.

I decided to read the sequel to The Bean Trees, Pigs in Heaven.  I highly recommend The Bean Trees.

July 2026

A Cold Day in Paradise

Steve Hamilton

Fiction 1998/ 277 pages

three-hearts

I was searching around for a mystery series … at least to read a few.  Two of my friends suggested Steve Hamilton, and the first book in his series is A Cold Day in Paradise.   The setting was very appealing to, as I was born and raised in Detroit.  But the setting alone would not have made it a good read.  It needed some good authorship, too, and this book was a page turner!  I am definitely going on to the second book in the series.

Alex McKnight was a cop in Detroit when he was shot three times, and his partner was killed.  Alex still carries a bullet in his body, too close to his heart to be removed.  That was 14 years ago.  Since then, Alex has taken his 3/4 disability pay and moved to Paradise to be a private investigator.  Paradise is a small town on the shore of Lake Superior, in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula.

So how is it that Maximillian Rose, who is still in prison for his crimes against McKnight and his partner, had decided now is the time to seek revenge? We really don’t know how the timing came about, but clearly the effort was being put forth, with a couple of seemingly unrelated murders as the non-Rose perpetrator gets closer to McKnight.  Actually, I thought the explanation of the conclusion was a bit unclear.  At least it was to me.

My major issue with Hamilton’s work is his total lack of women characters.  The only one with any part to play at all in the novel was Sylvia, the woman Alex has/had an affair with.  I don’t know if Hamilton is sexist and doesn’t think a cop or a technician can be a woman, or if he just has no capacity to develop and write women characters.  That will be my litmus test in the second book of his that I read.

Yes, I recommend A Cold Day in Paradise for its pure fun as a mystery.

July 2026

The Fountains of Silence

Ruta Sepetys

Historical Fiction 2019 | 499 pages

four-hearts

Josie, I don’t know how you do it.  You always unearth not-well-known long books from a few years ago, and they are always stellar, such as this one, The Fountains of Silence by Ruta Sepetys.

This is a sweeping, beautifully written historical novel about a time in history you may not know much about, 40 years, beginning in 1939, of leadership under Generalisimo Francisco Franco in Spain.  Franco was an oppressive, authoritarian leader, a dictator, a fascist, a cruel leader who cared more about himself than his people.  The Fountains of Silence is about what Franco does to attract US investment, hoping to fund his government.  He turns old buildings into beautiful structures, and encourages complete support for the oil tycoons, journalists, professors, financial managers and others who want to explore how Spain can serve their business development.

Our main character is Daniel Matheson, who is visiting Madrid with his oil business owner father and Dallas, Texas socialite mother, for much of the summer of 1957.  Ana is a worker in the hotel, who must obey rules the management insists upon, such as not talking shout their own personal lives, and never being with a resident unless fulfilling a specific request.   Daniel falls in love with Ana Torres Moreno,  but that definitely breaks all the rules.

We follow their relationship as Ana shows Daniel some of the wonders of Madrid.  He also becomes friends with her sister Julia and brother Rafa, and Julia’s baby.  There are interesting sub-plots.  These criss-crossing threads keep me engaged in the book.  It is an easy read.  Took me just over two days. 

A major sub-plot is that Daniel’s father wants Daniel to assume leadership of his oil business in Dallas but Daniel wants to be a photojournalist.  He meets Ben, who works at a major magazine and encourages and mentors Daniel in his photojournalist efforts.

And there is Fuga, who wants to crawl his way out of poverty by becoming a bullfighter.

And why are there empty caskets in the pile of infant coffins that came from the orphanage Insula, who specializes in the adoption of young children.?

And who is sending Ana threatening notes and, for heaven’s sake, why?

I really enjoyed Fountains of Silence,  I learned a great deal about Spain, and also explored family dynamics, love, mystery, resistance to social change, career decisions, cultural clashes on minor issues, such as what shoes are important to wear to a particular event, the role of adoption during a post civil war occurrence, and hidden truths.  My most important learning is the one the author seemed to want for us … to explore the silences we all keep; the value of silence; the debilitating aspects of silence; the release of silence; the necessity of being silent no more.

I completely recommend The Fountains of Silence.

June 2026

March

Geraldine Brooks

Fiction 2005/ 280 pages

three-hearts

I don’t know, I just couldn’t quite enjoy this book.  The plot is wonderfully inventive.  This is the story of March, who is the father of Louisa May Alcott’s four little women, Meg, Jo, Amy, and Beth.  The storyline takes place in two venues/timelines, one when March is 39 and leaves his young women and his wife Marmee at home in Concord, Massachusetts.  He signs up for the Civil War as an idealist, a vegetarian, an abolitionist, an anti-slavery and pro-freedom revolutionary, and a chaplain.  The other story is about 20 years earlier when he meets and marries Marmee and begins to have daughters.  It is perhaps the plot itself, as creative as it is, that sours the book for me. Having read Little Women decades ago, I love the chapters where March is home with his family.

I find the chapters that tell the story of the Civil War to be boring, horror filled, brutal, barbaric, grim, sad, powerful, and violent, coupled with March’s debilitating inability to be a chaplain neither he nor his charges can be proud of.  Though, when he begins to teach young black children their letters, he finds his purpose and comes into his own.

Brooks is, of course, a magnificent writer.  Perhaps I am simply done with stories about past wars, at least for a while.

I can recommend this book to lovers of Geraldine Brooks.  It is another one of her many masterpieces. Enjoy March.  If you read it and love it, I would be pleased to read your review of it.

June 2026

Theo of Golden

Allen Levi

Fiction 2023 | 387 pages

two-hearts

I belong to a Facebook group, Book Club Favorites.  (Unfollowed two other groups.  Book readers are extremely prolific!

Anyway, over the last few months, Theo of Golden received an unbelievable number of posts and incited a plethora of discussion.

"You must read this book.  I loved it!”

"I fell asleep reading it.  Boring."

"An inspirational book about kindness."

"Too spiritual."

'I don't need a feel-good book to tell me to be kind."

"Might be my favorite book of all time."

"Way over-hyped."

"Loosely disguised Jesus figure."

I was curious to see where I would land.  There was very little middle ground. Readers loved it or hated it.

Virtually everyone wrote about the story, and no one wrote about the writing.  I will change that direction with my review.

Theo is a well-traveled, wealthy man of 86 who decides to move south from New York City for a year or so.  He moves to Golden, Georgia, and meets and befriends many people in this small Southern town.  On one of his first days, he enters The Chalice ... a coffee shop that makes European coffee just the way he likes it.  On the walls of The Chalice are 92 penciled and pen&ink portraits, created by a local artist.  We learn about how Theo buys each portrait, one at a time, and gives it to the person in the portrait, nearly always inspiring deep conversation. Theo is generous, kind, compassionate, and a superb listener.

That is the story line, and it is an interesting one. 

Unfortunately, I felt the writing was awful.  I don't know if Allen Levi did this on purpose, but it wrecked the book for me.  The character of Theo is one-dimensional, tracing paper thin in character development, sophomoric, shallow.  There is no depth, no texture, no nuance in his personality.  Much as I love debut novels, I will not be looking forward to his second book.

And the ending is contrived, all too convenient. Writing a letter to close up all the loose ends the author didn’t manage to do in the plot line is also a sign of an unsophisticated author.

I cannot think of a single person I would recommend read Theo of Golden. Therefore, by definition, this book receives two hearts.

June 2026

Many Books

Andrea Sigetich

Many genres | Thousands of pages

four-hearts

It has been ten years today since I started my blog, Dusty Shelves.  Hard to believe!  I still enjoy writing it and hope you still enjoy reading it too, at least once in a while.  First book I blogged on was Dead Wake by Erik Larson.  It received four hearts. Here is what the hearts mean.

four-heartsLike it a lot or loved it; I recommend it; put it on your list!

three-heartsLike it; I recommend, with some reservations.

two-heartsI don’t recommend it, though it was compelling enough for me to finish reading.

one-heartI couldn’t get through it

May 2026